Mary McNicol

January 27, 1930 - May 6, 2020
Mary McNicol

Gifts & Memorial Donations

Mary Clare McNicol, age 90, passed away on Wednesday, May 6th , 2020 at Calcutta Health Care following a lengthy illness.

Ms. McNicol was born in Wellsville, Ohio, on January 27th, 1930 and had lived her entire life in Wellsville. The daughter of the late Edward Leo McNicol and Kathryn Isabel McNicol, she was a graduate of Wellsville High School, class of 1947. She was employed at Potter’s Bank & Trust  as a teller and account specialist retiring in 1993 after 31 years. She was also previously  employed as a clerk at Bell’s Market in Wellsville. Ms. McNicol was a member of the Holy Trinity Parish, and a former member of the Immaculate Conception Church. She was actively involved with the Wellsville High School Alumni Activities Committee, and helped organize the 5 year alumni dinner, as well as the monthly spaghetti dinners.  Mary was also on the Save the Immaculate Conception Church Committee, and was a volunteer for Meals on Wheels.

Survivors include four nephews: Patrick M. McNicol of Wellsville, Cristopher E. McNicol and his wife Judy of Wellsville and their son William of Lakewood, Ohio, Timothy J. McNicol and his wife Maria and their daughters Jenna and Emily of Wellsville, and Scott A. McNicol, his wife Jennifer and their son Nicholas of Powell, Ohio.

In addition to her parents, preceding her in death was a brother: Thomas J. McNicol, and a sister-in-law: Elizabeth A. McNicol.

In compliance with Ohio State Regulations and in connection to the COVID-19 public health crisis, a private family service will be held at MacLean Chapel of Care Funeral and Cremation Specialists in Wellsville at 1pm on Tuesday, May 12th. Visitation (proper social distancing observed) will occur two hours prior to the service. Burial will take place at Saint Elizabeth’s Cemetery immediately following the service.

Donations may be made in Mary’s memory to the Wellsville High School Alumni Activities Committee at 201 3rd Street, Wellsville, Ohio.

Friends may view this obituary online, send condolences to the family or sign the guest book at


Tuesday, May 12, 2020
1:00 PM

Care Funeral and Cremation Specialists – MacLEAN Chapel - Directions
509 Riverside Avenue
Wellsville, Ohio 43968


Tuesday, May 12, 2020

St. Elizabeth Cemetery - Directions
Wilson Avenue
Wellsville, Ohio 43968

Purchase Flowers

Tribute Wall

Please feel free to sign the guestbook or share a memory

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

  • May 07, 2020
    Toni Corbisello Figley says:
    Condolences to the family of Mary Clare. I worked with Mary for many years on the Wellsville Alumni Activities Committee. She actually taught me the proper way to set a table. She will be missed by many. Rest in peace Mary.

  • May 07, 2020
    Jessie Hawk McMenamin says:
    Mary Clare was one of my Mom's ( Mary Hawk) dearest friends. Their friendship began when they worked together at Bell's Market. Mary Clare was also my sponsor when I made my Confirmation. Sending my deepest sympathy to the family on her passing. May she rest in peace.

  • May 08, 2020
    Fred and Mary Frost says:
    So sorry to hear this. Mary Clare was a great friend! She will be missed. Our deepest sympathy and prayers to the entire family.

  • May 08, 2020
    Aaron M Clark says:
    Mary Clare was a good friend of my grandmother's and was always nice to me when we spoke. Prayers and sympathy from the Hawk family.

  • May 08, 2020
    steven r clark says:
    Our family sends our sympathy to your family..a sad time for so many reasons. She, Tom & Liz go back a long time with my family. God Bless to all..Steve